Is Credit Repair Ethical?

Most Americans know that it is possible to have information changed on your credit report, but many are concerned about whether or not it is ethical.

This begs the question: If you were to start up a credit reporting agency, how would you go about it? After all, isn't that what Experian, Trans Union and Equifax have done?

Well what would you do? The process requires that you contact a variety of financial institutions, taxing authorities, collection agencies, etc. and then propose to pool that information into one record source that could be mutually accessed by all participating members. The credit agencies love to say, "don't shoot the messenger", but in fact, they have solicited, finagled, begged, pleaded and bought their way into the "messenger" position. This is the very reason why there are 3 main reporting agencies and not just one – competition for business!

Once you understand that, the Fair Credit Reporting Act makes a lot of sense. You see, since 1971, and with numerous amendments and subsequent Acts passed by Congress, the issue at stake is not their capacity to report, but rather, the privacy of US citizens.

Trust me; these agencies would report your age, sex, religion, bank account balances, health records, blood pressure, driving record, and your grades from elementary school if they thought they could get away with it. The core purpose of the FCRA and other Acts like the Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act is to place the burden of proof upon the credit agencies, and NOT the consumer.

It is as if the credit agencies are writing a book on every financial relationship you've had since age 18, and they offer, on the cheap, to sell that book to anyone who wants to join the book club. When a consumer attempts to challenge the information contained on their report, they are merely calling for a "fact check" with the publisher. The FCRA requires that information contained on a consumer report be 100% accurate, complete, and verifiable.

Back to the ethics question. Let's say I own a million-dollar home with a million-dollar mortgage balance. I've never been late. Is it really EVERYBODY'S business to know how much I owe, when the debt was taken out, whom is obligated on the debt, the current balance, which bank, the payment amount – and ALL of that in addition to the payment history? Wouldn't it be sufficient to state "George pays his mortgage on time?" A person inclined to privacy might want to have that information deleted, even IF they pay on time. The fact that someone chooses to challenge the negative information is merely an expression of their right to privacy. Let's hope we never get too cavalier about that.

I am a member of the Financial Empowerment Network Team and Prime Financial Credit Services